PSL16 Map Selection

[t-34]

Very nice maps Roo!

1.B 6.A 11.A
2.A 7.B 12.B
3.A 8.B 13.B
4.A 9.A 14.A
5.A 10.A. 15.B

[Rooster]

Thanks everyone - I gave it my all

@Nappy - Heh! No Foolin' you!
Special thanks on the compliment - fellow modder and all
If you like Spinal Tap then check out Pahoehoe

@Reagent thanks for being the glue...
and yes everything I made is for everyone once the toaster is awarded

Hope all you Scrumaniacs have a bang up - ripsnortin' - good ole' time!

[stinkfingers]

since roo went to all the trouble, and the maps seem cool in the snaps, i figure i should peruse.
----------

kk: had the pleasure of a tour w/roo. those maps rock. lots of topography changes, coo trix, some gently rollers, some flats, some cliffs. very nice variations. i like that none of them really lend themselves to slow, drawn out bm scrum matches. those types of maps heavily favor low pingers, whereas this batch should even out some of the high ping disadvantage IMO.

they are all a's really, but i'll rank according to my preference for map types:
1. B; 2 B; 3 A; 4 B; 5 A
6. A; 7. B; 8. A; 9. A; 10. A
11. B; 12. A; 13. A; 14. A; 15. A

very fine work mr. rooster. this will be the best season ever! all hail Sparklemotion! (ez gliders TM).

[Reagent X]

Thanks to everyone who casted their votes. I am going to tally them up now. So if you have looked through them and have an opinion, NOW IS THE TIME TO VOTE QUICKLY!

Here are my votes:
1. C
2. A
3. B
4. A
5. C
6. B
7. A
8. B
9. B
10. B
11. A
12. C
13. A
14. B
15. B

[The Professor]

I will trust in the prior evaluations - I adapt well to most maps.

Roo - a special thanks for the map making.

While I did not inspect each closely, this simply speaks to the fact that I (and I would wager everyone else) knows you make superb maps. Some of the nuances I miss, as I typically just adjust my game play to the terrain. As a result, it probably seems that you efforts are not appreciated. Nothing could be further from the truth - you are the "gorrilla grip" that helps keep it together.

Prof

[Reagent X]

TALLY so far (A =2 points, B= 1 point, C = 0 points):

score name
15 Spinal Tap
11 Maudlin Moor
11 Pahoehoe
11 Peccadillo Peak
11 Pugnacious Plateau
11 Zydeco Two-Step
10 Imbroglio Island
10 Metamorphic Mesa
9 Bludgeoned Bluff
8 Halitosis Hill
8 Rendition Ridge
7 Cantebury Canyon
7 Moonstruck
6 Laguna
5 Mutilation Meadow

We already played on Imbrogliio Island, so I will remove that. Then I will chop off the bottom two, and order the regular season in order of rank to keep the top maps for last. So far Spinal Tap is the Finals Map. Have you seen this map? It is pretty wild! At this point your vote can make a HUGE difference. I will keep the voting open until midnight tonight! Also we need to break the 5-way tie (!) for the playoffs map!

And don't be concerned about hurting Roo's feelings. It goes without saying that these are all incredible maps - and he knows we are truly appreciative! The voting process is more about everyone having a say in what kind of a season we want. There is tremendous variety on these maps. Each brings a unique characteristic to the gameplay. At this point it is more about expressing your preferences on whether you like mountainous or flat, large or small, air goals or not, lots of arrow or not so many, ones where you can see the whole map most of the time or not, not to mention the aesthetic of the colors and skies.

[TankerBel]

1. B
2. B
3. A
4. A
5. A
6. B
7. A
8. A
9. C
10. B
11. C
12. C
13. B
14. C
15. C

mmmm... all so yummy

[The Professor]

1B 2B 3A 4A 5A 6B 7B 8A 9B 10B 11B 12C 13A 14B 15B

Let's do dis!

[Reagent X]

Okie dokie - map selections are locked and loaded. Thanks all!!

[TankerBel]

Looks good. Great playoff map btw.